Shelter Island, NY Luxury Homes for Sale and Real Estate

Shelter Island, NY Luxury Homes for Sale and Real Estate

Sort:

15 Results

61 S CARTWRIGHT RD, SHELTER ISLAND, NY 11964 - Image 013f25600f0e885e4ecf6dbe88c8ce76/3973799141

New Listing

61 S CARTWRIGHT RDSHELTER ISLAND, NY 11964

$2,230,000

5

4

3,262 SQ FT

Listing by Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

MLS® #: 1058792

7 WHEELER RD, SHELTER ISLAND, NY 11964 - Image d87a9961f2aa68b4e6f82982e60de297/1411990765

New Listing

7 WHEELER RDSHELTER ISLAND, NY 11964

$2,690,000

4

3

2,289 SQ FT

Listing by World Prop Intl Sea to Sky

MLS® #: 1048489

100 PECONIC, SHELTER ISLAND, NY 11964 - Image 31aaf78bc529c6ca2fcc48fe0e2b0fe0/2244800313

100 PECONICSHELTER ISLAND, NY 11964

$4,000,000

3

3

1,626 SQ FT

Listing by M Wein Realty Inc

MLS® #: 11507727

3 BEVAN PL, SHELTER ISLAND HEIGHTS, NY 11965 - Image a177f87b6f6bde9c1f22d86d29da38ba/2345917746

3 BEVAN PLSHELTER ISLAND HEIGHTS, NY 11965

$8,500,000

3

3

1,798 SQ FT

Listing by The Agency Hamptons

MLS® #: 11910781

100 PECONIC AVE, SHELTER ISLAND, NY 11964 - Image 26ad6a71bc05c3dda968d2dc06c4b735/1607869948

100 PECONIC AVESHELTER ISLAND, NY 11964

$4,000,000

3

3

N/A

Listing by Compass

MLS® #: 11863317

90 PECONIC AVE, SAG HARBOR, NY 11963 - Image d2cac5cb7f12dab471ac430935a903e1/585477166

90 PECONIC AVESAG HARBOR, NY 11963

$4,800,000

5

4

3,325 SQ FT

Listing by Serhant East End Llc

MLS® #: 1007669

2 PROSPECT AVE, SHELTER ISLAND HEIGHTS, NY 11965 - Image 908e0209de5685f1111b53a336c3b4ce/136942012

2 PROSPECT AVESHELTER ISLAND HEIGHTS, NY 11965

$2,700,000

6

3

5,900 SQ FT

Listing by Compass Greater Ny Llc

MLS® #: 1005789

3 CONRAD RD, SHELTER ISLAND, NY 11964 - Image 7da5ee3f50d00f585f48d7095b4253e6/3563725203

3 CONRAD RDSHELTER ISLAND, NY 11964

$2,395,000

4

4

2,000 SQ FT

Listing by Compass

MLS® #: 11780595

4 IRENE LN, SHELTER ISLAND, NY 11964 - Image 6d16ed5361318c57c3671f4f70390f8d/4264771532

4 IRENE LNSHELTER ISLAND, NY 11964

$1,850,000

4

3

2,600 SQ FT

Listing by Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

MLS® #: 1003398

9 MARGARET'S DR, SHELTER ISLAND, NY 11964 - Image 1de19879a81ebb514f976f741bee5656/2881974564

9 MARGARET'S DRSHELTER ISLAND, NY 11964

$5,000,000

4

6

5,530 SQ FT

Listing by Compass

MLS® #: 11716567

100 S MIDWAY RD, SHELTER ISLAND, NY 11964 - Image 5636ffdca634319e46f298f52cc54def/1709053776

100 S MIDWAY RDSHELTER ISLAND, NY 11964

$2,245,000

4

3

2,300 SQ FT

Listing by Dering Harbor Real Estate Llc

MLS® #: 11732344

9 LOCUST WOODS DR, SHELTER ISLAND, NY 11964 - Image cf976ff09496aee50e275c04f7c94805/2509472344

Virtual Tour

9 LOCUST WOODS DRSHELTER ISLAND, NY 11964

$2,995,000

4

5

3,856 SQ FT

Listing by Keller Williams Realty Greater

MLS® #: 981046

8 HILO DR, SHELTER ISLAND HEIGHTS, NY 11965 - Image 80d0ce28f2d2d5ae7ad5db25e8c404a7/2889412657

8 HILO DRSHELTER ISLAND HEIGHTS, NY 11965

$3,850,000

4

6

3,985 SQ FT

Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate

MLS® #: 962070

141 FERRY RD, SAG HARBOR, NY 11963 - Image 56923b1be7dd21f59233a09021f92b2b/3251132572

141 FERRY RDSAG HARBOR, NY 11963

$3,999,000

4

7

5,500 SQ FT

Listing by Atlas Sales Realty

MLS® #: 930022

100 S FERRY RD, SHELTER ISLAND, NY 11964 - Image 6183a86d2b3729c824297344bc3f04bf/1084297600

Virtual Tour

100 S FERRY RDSHELTER ISLAND, NY 11964

$4,295,000

6

8

5,622 SQ FT

Listing by Douglas Elliman Real Estate

MLS® #: 864101

Updated 3:54pm UTC- 8/27/2026

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data exchange of OneKey MLS. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Copyright © 2026 OneKey MLS. All Rights Reserved.

Updated 3:54pm UTC- 8/27/2026

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data exchange (“IDX”) program of State Listings Inc. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than RE/MAX Sparrow Realty, are indicated by detailed information about them such as the name of the listing firms. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Copyright© 2026 MyStateMLS. All Rights Reserved.