Fire Island, NY Luxury Homes for Sale and Real Estate

Fire Island, NY Luxury Homes for Sale and Real Estate

Sort:

30 Results

409 OCEAN WALK, FIRE ISLAND PINES, NY 11782 - Image 431f93ca3da2e5329044473d65d4046c/2511898608

New Listing

409 OCEAN WALKFIRE ISLAND PINES, NY 11782

$1,950,000

2

3

1,768 SQ FT

Listing Broker: D Katen Fire Island Prop Ltd

MLS® #: 1063143

35 GALE AVE, OCEAN BEACH, NY 11770 - Image 8f3675d3705d21bea30d273fca2a5331/3332215428

New Listing

35 GALE AVEOCEAN BEACH, NY 11770

$2,699,000

5

3

1,840 SQ FT

Listing Broker: The Agency Northshore Ny

MLS® #: 1061977

1 WEST AVE, PATCHOGUE, NY 11772 - Image 4e9fd5ccec5412307eda307dd3505e61/1790521615

New Listing

1 WEST AVEPATCHOGUE, NY 11772

$3,000,000

4

4

2,100 SQ FT

Listing Broker: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

MLS® #: 1052186

27 SUPERIOR ST, OCEAN BEACH, NY 11770 - Image 184e76b5db9ed07f492736fad4a14e75/156757346

New Listing

27 SUPERIOR STOCEAN BEACH, NY 11770

$2,900,000

4

4

852 SQ FT

Listing Broker: The Agency Northshore Ny

MLS® #: 1048092

221 BAY WALK, FIRE ISLAND PINES, NY 11782 - Image e53732e49f4af410570bbaf9cd836de8/132336449

221 BAY WALKFIRE ISLAND PINES, NY 11782

$2,100,000

3

4

2,220 SQ FT

Listing Broker: Netter Real Estate Inc

MLS® #: 1054538

59 LAUREL AVE, OCEAN BEACH, NY 11770 - Image ac9d4711f42adc31b9c21715132ea09c/1032650437

59 LAUREL AVEOCEAN BEACH, NY 11770

$3,490,000

4

2

1,260 SQ FT

Listing Broker: Fire Island Sales And Rentals

MLS® #: 1033203

307 SHADY WALK, SAYVILLE, NY 11782 - Image 132cf5aea135bdea051b438a7b16260c/2610594641

307 SHADY WALKSAYVILLE, NY 11782

$2,200,000

3

3

1,253 SQ FT

Listing Broker: Vinnie Petrarca Fire Island

MLS® #: 1033182

25 E BAYVIEW AVE, OCEAN BEACH, NY 11770 - Image 66a376bf098d54a7b9c2bc9bbcc30979/2090122924

Contingent

25 E BAYVIEW AVEOCEAN BEACH, NY 11770

$1,760,000

N/A

N/A

N/A

Listing Broker: Ucciferri Thomas J

MLS® #: 11898180

59 GALE AVE, OCEAN BEACH, NY 11770 - Image 1785fe84f2609e8dfaf01f0a0deecc37/2062456426

59 GALE AVEOCEAN BEACH, NY 11770

$4,200,000

3

2

1,834 SQ FT

Listing Broker: The Agency Northshore Ny

MLS® #: 1024784

2 OCEAN BAY BLVD, OCEAN BEACH, NY 11770 - Image 377d1441253db9ee1924d31c3dcf0f06/3211393604

2 OCEAN BAY BLVDOCEAN BEACH, NY 11770

$4,490,000

5

6

3,600 SQ FT

Listing Broker: Fire Island Sales And Rentals

MLS® #: 1026874

487 TARPON WALK, SAYVILLE, NY 11782 - Image 7935036cf22b7a2e163f6e4abc0ab7df/432352786

487 TARPON WALKSAYVILLE, NY 11782

$1,995,000

3

3

1,040 SQ FT

Listing Broker: Vinnie Petrarca Fire Island

MLS® #: 1026332

31 IVY AVE, OCEAN BEACH, NY 11770 - Image 8e64d54a30d1870b17027ef2a0995d8d/232741643

31 IVY AVEOCEAN BEACH, NY 11770

$1,800,000

4

4

1,248 SQ FT

Listing Broker: F I N Y Real Estate Co Llc

MLS® #: 1024856

46 CRESCENT AVE, OCEAN BEACH, NY 11770 - Image 5005913d5676085e6ff281748e621646/507483917

46 CRESCENT AVEOCEAN BEACH, NY 11770

$2,000,000

4

3

1,500 SQ FT

Listing Broker: F I N Y Real Estate Co Llc

MLS® #: 1024800

58 GALE AVE, OCEAN BEACH, NY 11770 - Image 3d1da7ed8a2616822b1e26f84395f1dd/3425510459

Pending

58 GALE AVEOCEAN BEACH, NY 11770

$3,099,000

5

3

1,336 SQ FT

Listing Broker: The Agency Northshore Ny

MLS® #: 1016728

52 LEWIS WALK, SAYVILLE, NY 11782 - Image 01b471043a4e8c34631f3d720676e985/3887754193

52 LEWIS WALKSAYVILLE, NY 11782

$2,500,000

4

5

1,488 SQ FT

Listing Broker: Summer Place Realty

MLS® #: 1017237

35 BAYVIEW WALK, SAYVILLE, NY 11782 - Image c7759fab17f117e469496902564596c0/1284770151

35 BAYVIEW WALKSAYVILLE, NY 11782

$1,750,000

7

8

2,352 SQ FT

Listing Broker: Summer Place Realty

MLS® #: 1017133

61 EVERGREEN AVE, OCEAN BEACH, NY 11770 - Image 30a4221c71d9eb311aa54cc0c3873ce6/2823144797

61 EVERGREEN AVEOCEAN BEACH, NY 11770

$5,100,000

5

4

2,099 SQ FT

Listing Broker: Wallace Rlty Sales & Vacation

MLS® #: 1009823

18 OCEAN BAY BLVD, OCEAN BEACH, NY 11770 - Image a27bb0b864de5815eca9205c3c757cea/3085126619

18 OCEAN BAY BLVDOCEAN BEACH, NY 11770

$3,600,000

5

4

2,785 SQ FT

Listing Broker: F I N Y Real Estate Co Llc

MLS® #: 1007104

362 OCEAN WALK, FIRE ISLAND PINES, NY 11782 - Image 614510e4cb6389d71c938e3010a15efa/3394622677

362 OCEAN WALKFIRE ISLAND PINES, NY 11782

$2,500,000

6

7

3,000 SQ FT

Listing Broker: Vinnie Petrarca Fire Island

MLS® #: 1006861

605 SHORE WALK, FIRE ISLAND PINES, NY 11782 - Image 90c35fe24ed9f9965bdc41310fb3eada/871495096

605 SHORE WALKFIRE ISLAND PINES, NY 11782

$1,799,000

4

4

2,000 SQ FT

Listing Broker: Vinnie Petrarca Fire Island

MLS® #: 1006212

317 SKY WALK, SAYVILLE, NY 11782 - Image b912b69e0d75223896d9b2b49373249a/2494412038

317 SKY WALKSAYVILLE, NY 11782

$2,075,000

7

5

3,444 SQ FT

Listing Broker: Douglas Elliman Real Estate

MLS® #: 995314

39 EAST WALK, OCEAN BEACH, NY 11770 - Image 08862188e6f4a5ff6df631c4ac2b5875/2412385596

Pending

39 EAST WALKOCEAN BEACH, NY 11770

$1,999,000

4

3

2,160 SQ FT

Listing Broker: Your Home Sold Guaranteed Rlty

MLS® #: 000078

29 E BAYVIEW AVE, OCEAN BEACH, NY 11770 - Image 2f14ff02418e72693e6886b1e5655b09/970124040

Pending

29 E BAYVIEW AVEOCEAN BEACH, NY 11770

$1,850,000

3

2

1,296 SQ FT

Listing Broker: Your Home Sold Guaranteed Rlty

MLS® #: 998635

17 SUPERIOR ST, OCEAN BEACH, NY 11770 - Image c741e972f82b176ecc8b9d32d9834f57/1235870052

17 SUPERIOR STOCEAN BEACH, NY 11770

$2,999,000

4

4

1,500 SQ FT

Listing Broker: The Agency Northshore Ny

MLS® #: 994515

Updated 3:54pm UTC- 8/27/2026

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data exchange of OneKey MLS. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Copyright © 2026 OneKey MLS. All Rights Reserved.

Updated 3:54pm UTC- 8/27/2026

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data exchange (“IDX”) program of State Listings Inc. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than RE/MAX Sparrow Realty, are indicated by detailed information about them such as the name of the listing firms. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Copyright© 2026 MyStateMLS. All Rights Reserved.