$74,900

940 E Windfall Rd, Olean, NY 14760

1,743 sq ft

Listed by Wny Metro Roberts Realty, Merritt Kreutzer
716-668-2500

Status: Active

MLS® #B1720316

Property description for 940 E Windfall Rd, Olean, NY 14760

This four-bedroom home in the Portville Central School District offers a unique and flexible layout, generous outdoor storage and an opportunity to make it your own. Inside, you'll find two bedrooms on the first floor and two upstairs, plus an upstairs living area with a vaulted wood-plank ceiling that opens to the upper deck. A stone fireplace with pellet insert on the first floor adds character, and the brick mudroom includes laundry space. Outside is a covered porch, partly fenced yard, attached one-car carport, shed and detached two-car garage. Being sold as-is, with no repairs or credits from the sellers, and with all remaining contents included. A roof leak has caused second-floor interior water damage; buyers should evaluate for possible mold and structural issues. The home has a private well and septic system. Heat is oil-fueled forced air, and a propane tank is on the property but is not being utilized. Photos and video show the current condition. Cash or renovation financing only. For a buyer ready to renovate, this property offers space, character and room to bring new ideas to life.

QUICK OVERVIEW

Built in 1957
$43 / Sq Ft
3 parking spaces
Oil, Forced Air
1 day on website
0.3903 acres lot

INTERIOR

BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION

EXTERIOR AND LOT

UTILITIES

AREA AND SCHOOLS

FINANCIAL INFO

Price per square foot and days on website are not provided values and are calculated by REMAX.

Listing Agent Merritt Kreutzer

Listing Office Wny Metro Roberts Realty, 7166682500

Updated Thursday, August 27, 2026 at 3:54:45 PM

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data exchange (IDX) program of the New York State Alliance MLS. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than New York State Alliance, are indicated by detailed information about them such as the name of the listing firms. All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. Neither the listing broker(s) nor New York State Alliance shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints, and shall be held totally harmless. Copyright © 2026 New York State Alliance and participating MLS's - CNYIS, UNYREIS and WNYREIS. All Rights Reserved.

NEIGHBORHOOD

About the Zip Code 14760 Neighborhood

The character of Zip Code 14760 is exemplified by its calm environment. Most areas in Zip Code 14760 are especially quiet, as the streets are usually very tranquil.

Learn more about Zip Code 14760

CLIMATE RISK FOR 14760

HOMEBUYER'S HUB

How Much Should You Offer on a House?

FIRST-TIME HOMEBUYER'S HUB

10 Tips for Getting the Best Mortgage Rate

Comparable listings to
940 E Windfall Rd, Olean, NY 14760

272 HAMILTON AVE, OLEAN, NY 14760 - Image f115893acb3679904c7e30eda28978a8/857568235

Updated

$74,900

272 HAMILTON AVEOLEAN, NY 14760

1,153 SQ FT

Listing by Howard Hanna Professionals - Olean - R1696374

MLS® #: R1696374

2890 ROUTE 305, CUBA, NY 14727 - Image f955ac49f700394d8915fc1b4822f013/732233727

Virtual Tour

Pending

$69,900

2890 ROUTE 305CUBA, NY 14727

1,216 SQ FT

Listing by Landquest Inc. - S1666785

MLS® #: S1666785

308 IRVING ST, OLEAN, NY 14760 - Image cdd3c6c1d1636aaaae9f0af31fcfd4c9/3392744837

Updated

$74,900

308 IRVING STOLEAN, NY 14760

1,490 SQ FT

Listing by Howard Hanna Professionals - Olean - R1671031

MLS® #: R1671031

3 STONE ST, CUBA, NY 14727 - Image 9bca75a8fd648dc8d26711ccc88885ce/1887224178

Virtual Tour

Pending

$85,000

3 STONE STCUBA, NY 14727

3,090 SQ FT

Listing by Era Team Vp-olean - R1674784

MLS® #: R1674784

New Listing

$80,000

115 S 3RD STOLEAN, NY 14760

1,871 SQ FT

Listing by Exp-premier Listings Team - R1718908

MLS® #: R1718908

903 W HENLEY ST, OLEAN, NY 14760 - Image 034bc4d2565b2c9d652799db955322f3/2291161281

Updated

Pending

$63,000

903 W HENLEY STOLEAN, NY 14760

1,484 SQ FT

Listing by Howard Hanna Professionals - Olean - R1680932

MLS® #: R1680932

108 N 4TH ST, OLEAN, NY 14760 - Image f4516d80f3449271844397798d21fd86/1092153248

Virtual Tour

Pending

$78,000

108 N 4TH STOLEAN, NY 14760

2,388 SQ FT

Listing by Howard Hanna Professionals - Olean - R1694653

MLS® #: R1694653

754 GARDEN AVE, OLEAN, NY 14760 - Image 5b3103bf0faf5f2e2485e2d8887821fd/2701883880

Updated

$84,900

754 GARDEN AVEOLEAN, NY 14760

1,120 SQ FT

Listing by 3d Real Estate Llc - B1630513

MLS® #: B1630513

427 N 9TH ST, OLEAN, NY 14760 - Image 2cef187ee0ca25827522bb3eb74000d3/516924969

Pending

$89,900

427 N 9TH STOLEAN, NY 14760

1,232 SQ FT

Listing by Exp-premier Listings Team - R1711892

MLS® #: R1711892

$85,000

22 MAPLE AVEFRIENDSHIP, NY 14739

2,256 SQ FT

Listing by Genesee River Realty - R1704613

MLS® #: R1704613

11 MAPLE AVE, FRIENDSHIP, NY 14739 - Image 3e7a93a3f2e8659f3c4ee63aa2300ba2/187365093

New Listing

Virtual Tour

$84,900

11 MAPLE AVEFRIENDSHIP, NY 14739

1,411 SQ FT

Listing by Landquest Inc. - S1720243

MLS® #: S1720243

$84,900

37 N 3RD STALLEGANY, NY 14706

2,048 SQ FT

Listing by Howard Hanna Professionals - Olean - R1708259

MLS® #: R1708259

333 N 5TH ST, OLEAN, NY 14760 - Image ca737fefb7f0ccea4cf440213ff2c163/589175104

New Listing

$89,900

333 N 5TH STOLEAN, NY 14760

1,546 SQ FT

Listing by Exp-premier Listings Team - R1720950

MLS® #: R1720950

206 TOMPKINS ST, OLEAN, NY 14760 - Image 0581b5d05b34ae6473ca01ec8afbf08c/3999573098

New Listing

$69,900

206 TOMPKINS STOLEAN, NY 14760

1,188 SQ FT

Listing by Howard Hanna Professionals - Olean - R1722322

MLS® #: R1722322

16 E WATER ST, FRIENDSHIP, NY 14739 - Image 6d7d9478414a6ee8cd3379ec3a2afa2e/1735914102

Pending

$79,000

16 E WATER STFRIENDSHIP, NY 14739

1,032 SQ FT

Listing by Homestar Realty - B1700625

MLS® #: B1700625

$75,000

5 2ND AVEFRANKLINVILLE, NY 14737

1,832 SQ FT

Listing by Era Team Vp Real Estate - Arcade - B1701577

MLS® #: B1701577

59 LILLIBRIDGE RD, PORTVILLE, NY 14770 - Image 1480f9e049a939d33b5d8b1eb9a3236e/448603473

Updated

$90,000

59 LILLIBRIDGE RDPORTVILLE, NY 14770

1,288 SQ FT

Listing by Real Estate Pros & More - R1681636

MLS® #: R1681636

202 E PINE ST, OLEAN, NY 14760 - Image 89ba4d3e6d7415edbd4b48cad0d8afbb/1505443342

Updated

$89,900

202 E PINE STOLEAN, NY 14760

2,072 SQ FT

Listing by Exp-premier Listings Team - R1673245

MLS® #: R1673245

451 HORSE RUN RD, LITTLE GENESEE, NY 14754 - Image d5b60b620727b272085b70eb5f2beccb/551775335

Virtual Tour

Pending

$74,900

451 HORSE RUN RDLITTLE GENESEE, NY 14754

980 SQ FT

Listing by Landquest Inc. - S1460774

MLS® #: S1460774

1505 W HENLEY ST, OLEAN, NY 14760 - Image 2005d23c8ddef225f18a119c91128357/4187936953

Updated

Pending

$69,900

1505 W HENLEY STOLEAN, NY 14760

1,252 SQ FT

Listing by Howard Hanna Professionals - Olean - R1688812

MLS® #: R1688812

Comparable Listings

Get Real Estate Advice

Enter your email for REMAX's HomeHQ newsletter. Grab market updates, expert selling tips, and real estate advice.

By clicking "Sign Up" below, you agree to receive marketing calls, texts, or emails placed by or on behalf of RE/MAX, LLC and/or your local REMAX franchised office, even if your phone number is on a Do Not Call List. You agree that calls or texts may be automated and/or sent with an artificial or prerecorded voice. Consent is not a condition of purchase. Message/data rates may apply. You also agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You may unsubscribe at any time.

Voted the Most Trusted Agents in Real Estate*

FIND A REMAX AGENT

940 E Windfall Rd, Olean, NY 14760

Property description for 940 E Windfall Rd, Olean, NY 14760

QUICK OVERVIEW

INTERIOR

BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION

EXTERIOR AND LOT

UTILITIES

AREA AND SCHOOLS

FINANCIAL INFO

NEIGHBORHOOD

CLIMATE RISK FOR 14760