$329,000

2134 Progress St, Eureka, CA 95501

1,830 sq ft

Listed by Coldwell Banker Sellers Realty, Sandra 'sandi' Deluca
707-822-5971

Status: Active

MLS® #273143

Property description for 2134 Progress St, Eureka, CA 95501

Unique Eureka opportunity! This private-feeling property offers a 1,860+ sq ft two-story Victorian home ready for your vision, plus a renovated 1BR/1BA second dwelling with a newer roof, currently rented. The large, mostly level lot feels like your own private world while just minutes from downtown, with impressive city-light views. Zoned R-2 multifamily, the property offers potential for future development, expansion or additional housing, subject to City of Eureka requirements and approvals. Housing laws continue to evolve, potentially creating additional opportunities. Verify zoning, occupancy, permitting and development potential with the City. Build sweat equity, create lasting value and potentially generational wealth through your investment!

QUICK OVERVIEW

Built in 1895
$180 / Sq Ft
1 parking space
Wall Furnace
60 days on website
0.46 acres lot

INTERIOR

BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION

EXTERIOR AND LOT

UTILITIES

AREA AND SCHOOLS

Price per square foot and days on website are not provided values and are calculated by REMAX.

Listing Agent Sandra 'sandi' Deluca

Listing Office Coldwell Banker Sellers Realty, 7078224337

Updated Thursday, August 27, 2026 at 4:00:26 PM

Based on information from the Humboldt Association of REALTORS®. All data, including all measurements and calculations of area, is obtained from various sources and has not been, and will not be verified by broker for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Copyright © 2025 Humboldt Association of REALTORS®. All Rights Reserved.

NEIGHBORHOOD

About the Fairfield Neighborhood

One of the unique aspects of Fairfield is that it contains both vibrant and quiet areas. Although this part of the city is not known for its lively atmosphere, with the nightlife venues in nearby neighborhoods, it is easy to find a place to grab a drink since they are generally located close by. At the same time, this area is very quiet, as there are generally low levels of noise from traffic.

Learn more about Fairfield

Car friendly

Excellent access to freeways and/or major arteries, with almost no chance of parking problems

Daycares

At least one daycare within a short walk

Groceries

Wide variety of groceries within a few minutes' walk

Restaurants

Wide variety of restaurants within a short drive, including some within walking distance

Shopping

Wide variety of shops within a short drive, including some within walking distance

CLIMATE RISK FOR 95501

HOMEBUYER'S HUB

How Much Should You Offer on a House?

FIRST-TIME HOMEBUYER'S HUB

10 Tips for Getting the Best Mortgage Rate

Comparable listings to
2134 Progress St, Eureka, CA 95501

$349,500

1523 WILLIAMS STEUREKA, CA 95501

950 SQ FT

Listing by Corcoran Icon Properties Eureka - Jessika Chapman

MLS® #: 273035

1225 9TH ST, EUREKA, CA 95501 - Image b2481e85e9c6b3c04198d29bce402ce0/3363319506

Virtual Tour

$349,900

1225 9TH STEUREKA, CA 95501

1,468 SQ FT

Listing by Community Realty / Dc - Don Chin

MLS® #: 273338

1704 I ST, EUREKA, CA 95501 - Image 443d0f8361f89d526f5120ffb53981be/3057039718

New Listing

3D Virtual Tour

$329,000

1704 I STEUREKA, CA 95501

1,500 SQ FT

Listing by Corcoran Icon Properties Arcata - Janna Walsh

MLS® #: 273507

3354 NEVADA ST, EUREKA, CA 95503 - Image e60e382cc37dabaab3a3162723f5a6d6/315878986

Pending

$319,000

3354 NEVADA STEUREKA, CA 95503

1,144 SQ FT

Listing by Coldwell Banker Cutten Realty - Joe Matteoli

MLS® #: 272991

3421 UNION ST, EUREKA, CA 95503 - Image 89bec9440fe9c4100e7253f0959a35e4/2234914369

Pending

$325,000

3421 UNION STEUREKA, CA 95503

890 SQ FT

Listing by Corcoran Icon Properties Eureka - Zach Levich

MLS® #: 273268

$319,500

2231 ALBEE ST # 000EUREKA, CA 95501

2,260 SQ FT

Listing by Benchmark Realty Group/ Mb - Mark Burtchett

MLS® #: 273030

1194 FRESHWATER RD, EUREKA, CA 95503 - Image ebbabdfef4b7d65cd0d52a2359c4fd5a/3839202825

Updated

$320,000

1194 FRESHWATER RDEUREKA, CA 95503

1,488 SQ FT

Listing by Remax Humboldt Realty - Kimi Matsuda

MLS® #: 271968

1985 PENINSULA DR, ARCATA, CA 95521 - Image cb5913ab898ed1025ba52bbec6cd7f66/2362460212

Updated

$299,000

1985 PENINSULA DRARCATA, CA 95521

908 SQ FT

Listing by The Real Estate Broker - Thomas Walker

MLS® #: 270631

821 SUMMER ST, EUREKA, CA 95501 - Image 676b437d24cbc99e610af8b2a76a4cae/1388672744

Updated

$285,000

821 SUMMER STEUREKA, CA 95501

1,391 SQ FT

Listing by The Real Estate Broker - Thomas Walker

MLS® #: 271645

2228 SUMMER ST, EUREKA, CA 95501 - Image 2c2681f48a708cacb137077a49c83785/827219911

Pending

$364,500

2228 SUMMER STEUREKA, CA 95501

980 SQ FT

Listing by Ming Tree, Inc. - Joshua Wayland Mohland

MLS® #: 273311

1721 WEST AVE, EUREKA, CA 95501 - Image 18e479c084bd7886f4e09d1ad332d9d1/4278104263

New Listing

Open House

$339,000

1721 WEST AVEEUREKA, CA 95501

1,100 SQ FT

Listing by Corcoran Icon Properties Eureka - Zach Levich

MLS® #: 273376

420 HIDDEN VALLEY RD, BAYSIDE, CA 95524 - Image 1c90f649184cbffa953b00e1eb63aa18/1629385130

Updated

Virtual Tour

$329,000

420 HIDDEN VALLEY RDBAYSIDE, CA 95524

1,800 SQ FT

Listing by Corcoran Icon Properties Eureka - Jessika Chapman

MLS® #: 272837

KING SALMON AVE, EUREKA, CA 95503 - Image 7838e69f56cad7685b976d16cece9bed/3820880938

Virtual Tour

Pending

$284,500

KING SALMON AVEEUREKA, CA 95503

672 SQ FT

Listing by Coldwell Banker Cutten Realty - Tina Christensen

MLS® #: 273371

2606 ALBEE ST, EUREKA, CA 95501 - Image 2db1014edbac1a4847845eade07b6002/742955928

New Listing

3D Virtual Tour

$289,000

2606 ALBEE STEUREKA, CA 95501

868 SQ FT

Listing by Corcoran Icon Properties Eureka - Tom Hunt

MLS® #: 273471

2917 C ST, EUREKA, CA 95501 - Image b8cc1ad01ab0e8a7431f300710c93f8c/2371712468

New Listing

Virtual Tour

$385,000

2917 C STEUREKA, CA 95501

1,149 SQ FT

Listing by Corcoran Icon Properties Arcata - Brigitte Benson

MLS® #: 273387

$339,000

1475 HOOVER STEUREKA, CA 95501

1,027 SQ FT

Listing by Remax Humboldt Realty - Brandon Brown

MLS® #: 273152

7526 ELK RIVER CT, EUREKA, CA 95503 - Image a185cd3e7beb4374cf4352775e26f9fc/2377740955

Open House

Virtual Tour

$325,000

7526 ELK RIVER CTEUREKA, CA 95503

1,216 SQ FT

Listing by Coldwell Banker Cutten Realty - Mike & Marci Pigg

MLS® #: 273501

7544 ELK RIVER CT, EUREKA, CA 95503 - Image 58459e9a89ee49565d2fa89597e295a6/2800131592

New Listing

Open House

$375,000

7544 ELK RIVER CTEUREKA, CA 95503

1,514 SQ FT

Listing by Redwood Realty - Jenifer Charleswell

MLS® #: 273531

$399,000

1840 QUAKER STEUREKA, CA 95501

1,462 SQ FT

Listing by Corcoran Icon Properties Eureka - Tom Hunt

MLS® #: 273175

2146 ALBEE ST, EUREKA, CA 95501 - Image 2e945a3478a8e009fa0f584d68d4bd9c/1616891947

Updated

3D Virtual Tour

$365,000

2146 ALBEE STEUREKA, CA 95501

1,345 SQ FT

Listing by Exp Realty of California, Inc. - Robin Quigley

MLS® #: 271901

Comparable Listings

Get Real Estate Advice

Enter your email for REMAX's HomeHQ newsletter. Grab market updates, expert selling tips, and real estate advice.

By clicking "Sign Up" below, you agree to receive marketing calls, texts, or emails placed by or on behalf of RE/MAX, LLC and/or your local REMAX franchised office, even if your phone number is on a Do Not Call List. You agree that calls or texts may be automated and/or sent with an artificial or prerecorded voice. Consent is not a condition of purchase. Message/data rates may apply. You also agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You may unsubscribe at any time.

Voted the Most Trusted Agents in Real Estate*

FIND A REMAX AGENT

2134 Progress St, Eureka, CA 95501

Property description for 2134 Progress St, Eureka, CA 95501

QUICK OVERVIEW

INTERIOR

BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION

EXTERIOR AND LOT

UTILITIES

AREA AND SCHOOLS

NEIGHBORHOOD

CLIMATE RISK FOR 95501